Log in
Apopka City Commission

Anderson berates Nesta about city administrator selection process

Posted

In Summary:

The city previously confirmed it posted the city administrator job through its Tyler system, but the only application and résumé it released to The Apopka Voice was from Brian Mater. At the November 18 meeting, Anderson called for broader recruitment for a job she said pays more than $200,000, while Nesta said he wants someone who understands Apopka well enough to get to work immediately. Mater defended his efforts to improve employee morale and said public criticism of staff could make recruitment harder.

Related: Apopka’s next City Administrator: A promise, a placeholder, and unanswered questions.

*****

Two weeks after Mayor Nick Nesta told commissioners he had a permanent city administrator lined up, the candidate’s name was still under wraps after the November 18 Apopka City Commission meeting.

But that didn't stop the city commission from asking.

Commissioner Nadia Anderson asked Nesta a series of questions about the search for a permanent city administrator. When was the job posted? How long was it open? How many people applied?

Nesta said he didn’t know.

When Anderson asked who served on the interviewing team, he said there was no team. 

"How is it transparent when you have a commissioner asking you, “When was the position posted? Anderson asked. "How long was it posted? How many applicants? Who was the interviewing team? Or we didn’t interview anyone?” That’s not alarming to anyone? To any commissioner, that’s not alarming? The second-largest municipality, and we don’t put up for the best person for the job. And with Amendment Three that just passed, this is an example of, to me, fraud, waste, abuse, all the above."

An announcement had been a possibility heading into Wednesday’s meeting. Public Information Director Steve Montiero had said Nesta expected to make a formal announcement “very soon,” although the published agenda did not list an appointment. When the subject came up Wednesday, the discussion turned to how the city was filling the job.

Anderson presses for details on recruitment

Anderson said she had received calls from residents who wanted to know how the selection process worked. She reminded Nesta that he had previously told commissioners the position was advertised. The city separately told The Apopka Voice that it posted the job through its Tyler system, but a public records request revealed interim city administrator Brian Mater as the lone applicant.

Anderson questioned whether the city had done enough to recruit for a job she said pays more than $200,000. She also questioned the government experience of Nesta, Mater and the city’s chief financial officer. She urged fellow commissioners to ask about the search and press the administration to advertise the position.

“We should get the best talent,” Anderson said. “And to say that we’re getting the best talent, we can’t say that when you didn’t advertise the position.”

Commissioner Yesenia Baron said she had also received calls and shared Anderson’s questions. She said she would leave it there because Anderson had already asked them.

Nesta describes what he wants in an administrator

Nesta used his mayor’s report to defend the team he is assembling. He said there had been “a lot of misinformation” at the meeting and pointed to progress on projects the city had budgeted for in previous years. In discussing what he looks for in city leaders, Nesta emphasized practical experience, critical thinking, and the ability to carry out the city’s plans.

“I have a master’s degree myself. I was in a program that I know some people, just because they have that paper, the degree on the wall, doesn’t mean they’re actually going to be able to accomplish what needs to get accomplished with that degree,” Nesta said. “I care about people that care about the community, put the residents first, first and foremost, and get the job done.”

Nesta also addressed the value of government experience. “You can say government experience all day, but if we’ve seen anything about government, they don’t get it right,” he said. “So we’re going to run this city like a business, and it is going to be proper and decent and in order.”

At the November 4 meeting, Nesta described his prospective choice as someone with “incredible experience” who had invested time and built relationships. On Wednesday, he said the permanent administrator should know Apopka well enough to start addressing its problems immediately. He also defended Mater’s interim appointment, saying he did not know anyone else who could step into that role while the city moved toward a permanent hire.

Mater defends his first two weeks

Mater, Nesta’s former campaign manager, began serving as interim administrator November 2. 

On Wednesday, Mater said improving employee morale had been his priority. He said he walked through the finance department with Vice Mayor Diane Velazquez and Baron to show them working conditions, including several employees sharing a room and some working in a closet. He said concerns about morale had surfaced during transition team discussions and again on his first day.

Mater also said he emailed Anderson on November 11 to reach out and offer to work with her. He said the email went unanswered. Anderson questioned whether she had received it, and Mater said he could check with the city’s information technology staff.

Mater said prospective employees and businesses can watch commission meetings and see how the city treats its staff. He said his children had seen the criticism directed at him and had wanted to defend him. He asked commissioners to consider how their public remarks could affect the city’s ability to recruit.

Key Points:

  • Nesta told commissioners on November 4 that a permanent administrator was already lined up. He did not identify the candidate at the November 18 meeting.
  • Nesta said he didn’t know the posting dates or applicant count and said there was no interviewing team.
  • Anderson urged the city to advertise the position and recruit candidates. Baron said she shared Anderson’s questions after hearing from residents.
  • The city confirmed it posted the opening through its Tyler system. Its response to a request for applications and résumés included only Mater’s records.
  • The city has yet to confirm when the permanent administrator will start or what role Mater will have afterward.
 
Apopka, Apopka City Commission, Apopka city administrator search, Nick Nesta, Nadia Anderson, Yesenia Baron, Brian Mater, Diane Velazquez, city administrator hiring, municipal government

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here