Log in
Apopka City Commission

Apopka ends Station Street development deal after delays and brownfield dispute

Commissioners voted unanimously to terminate the agreement with Standard Investments and Holdings and rescind the default they issued last month

Posted

In Summary:

Apopka and Standard Investments and Holdings agreed to end the Station Street development deal, reversing the commission’s default against the developer. Vice Mayor Diane Velazquez urged the city to stick to deadlines in future agreements, and Economic Development Director Antranette Forbes called for more specific requests for proposals. Mark Wilke of Benge Advisors said the site lacked environmental clearance and that the company had submitted paperwork twice without a response from the city.

*****

Apopka city commissioners voted unanimously to end the Station Street development agreement by mutual consent with Standard Investments and Holdings (SIH) after months of delays, environmental concerns, and a default the commission issued against the developer last month.

Related: Can a walkable downtown thrive in the heart of suburban sprawl? This city is putting that to the test.

The vote followed a letter from Orange County concerning an active brownfield condition on the property. SIH partner Tony Benge signed the mutual termination agreement Tuesday. The agreement also rescinds the commission’s default against SIH.

SIH is controlled by three separate entities: Benge Advisors, Green Swan LLC, and 654 Ventures. In the past six years, 654 Ventures faced at least three Apopka code enforcement violations. The owner of Benge Advisors faced a series of lawsuits over unpaid mortgage loans during the 2010s, according to the Orange County Comptroller's website.

Vice Mayor Diane Velazquez asked whether the issue had ultimately come down to the timeline and who had set it. Mayor Nick Nesta said both sides agreed to the timeline as part of the development deal.

“We did,” Velazquez said. “I think we missed an opportunity; well, the developer missed an opportunity to create our city downtown.” Economic Development Director Antranette Forbes said she agreed.

“If this is the best way to part ways, then we will part ways,” Velazquez said. “I am just going to echo that when we put out an RFP, and we set a timeline, that we don't keep delaying it as we did with this one.”

“One of the benefits of this mutual termination is that it showcases to the development community,” Forbes added. “If you do not meet the terms of the agreement, that we are intentional and aggressive about, then Apopka will be putting things in place so that there is some sort of result.”

Forbes said the city should be more specific about what it wants from future development partners so it receives stronger proposals.

Mark Wilke of Benge Advisors, the only person to speak during public comment on the item, disputed Velazquez’s and Forbes’ accounts. He said he had been prepared to walk away before hearing Velazquez’s remarks.

“There seems to still be some misconceptions about what’s going on,” Wilke said. “You can’t build on that piece of dirt. There’s an active brownfield site; it has no clearance.”

Wilke said the city or a developer would need to obtain a site rehabilitation completion order before proceeding with development on the property. He said SIH had submitted the required paperwork twice and received no response from the city.

“There is an active brownfield condition,” Wilke said. “We submitted those documents that were required on July 15, 2024, twice. No comment back from the city.”

“We were put in default with no communication with us,” Wilke continued. “Friday I followed up with Orange County about the site rehabilitation completion order, and it was denied. I can't touch; any developer in the audience cannot touch that site.”

Wilke said communication with the city could have resolved the dispute. He said he emailed Nesta and asked the commission to delay action until he could speak with officials. The commission voted unanimously last month to find SIH in default and voted Wednesday unanimously to end the agreement.

Key Points:

  • Commissioners voted unanimously to end the agreement by mutual consent and rescind last month’s default against SIH.
  • SIH partner Tony Benge signed the termination agreement Tuesday, ahead of the commission vote.
  • Mayor Nick Nesta said the city and the developer had agreed to the project timeline as part of the development deal.
  • Velazquez called for the city to hold future projects to their deadlines, and Forbes said the city should be more specific about what it wants from developers.
  • Wilke said the property lacked a site rehabilitation completion order and that Orange County had denied it.
Station Street development, downtown Apopka, Apopka City Commission, Standard Investments and Holdings, SIH, Benge Advisors, Tony Benge, Mark Wilke, Diane Velazquez, Antranette Forbes, Nick Nesta, Orange County, brownfield redevelopment

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here